New Year – new diet advice. The magazines are full of
pictures of tiny women, ‘weight-loss wonder’ diets and ‘super foods’. It is our national obsession with weight – you
can’t escape it wherever you go. Now even the political sphere is entering the
conversation, as Jo Swinson, Minister for Equality, criticises ‘fad diets and
fitness myths’, even as a group of doctors call for a ‘Minister for Fatness’
and a think tank proposes that overweight benefits claimants should have their
benefits cut unless they start exercising.
Everyone has an opinion on my body, what I do with it, and
what I put into it. Mostly I should eat less, and especially less cream and
cheese (Grazia would have a fit…)
Feminism is full of a backlash against this, preaching an
incredibly positive message of loving your body and eating what you want,
highlighting the ridiculousness of adverts that suggest we feel guilty for
eating a yoghurt. On the other hand, there is the vitally important post by Squeamish Bikini (www.squeamishbikini.com - Weighting
for Change), expressing her worries that this message too can be triggering for
sufferers of eating disorders. Differing messages of weight, diet, and exercise
bombard us everywhere we look.
This blog is not so much an impassioned piece of political
commentary as a confused stream of personal thinking – I really don’t know how
to feel about weight and exercise. And it isn’t just my confusion. A series of
tweets by the lovely @popbadger appeared on my news feed yesterday and really
resonated with me: ‘Weird being back at
the gym (in the changing room anyway). I was so nervous to come back that I sat
in my car outside for 15 minutes.” She went on to question her motives for
using the gym: “I think that I feel I’m letting down the feminist cause by
wanting to change my body.”
I share this fear. I worry about tweeting about exercise and
diets – I worry that I may inadvertently be triggering sufferers of eating
disorders, I worry that people will read these tweets and look down on me for
not being a “proper feminist”. I want to justify myself constantly with the
fact that it is for health or sport reasons. “It’s not about being thinner!” I
want to cry. But, in the interests of honesty, I must quietly whisper “but it
is maybe a little bit about being thinner.” I am ashamed to admit that I like
being slim (and I much prefer that word to ‘thin’) – and that I would like to
remain so whilst eating all the cheese, roast potatoes, and creamy food my
taste buds can take.
We live in a patriarchal society where we are constantly
bombarded with images of women with unattainable bodies – whether unattainable
through Photoshop or through the sheer amount of training that our wonderful
Olympic athletes do. We also live in a patriarchal society where women are
constantly being told what to do, what to eat, what to wear, what time we
should be safely at home by (before dark, unless accompanied by a big, strong
man).
I really want my feminism not to be any part of this. I want
everyone to get their hands off my flab and STOP TALKING ABOUT IT!! (This blog
post excepted, of course….!) I don’t want anyone to feel that they have to lose
weight, or that they are not beautiful unless they are a size 8 with abs like
Jessica Ennis. If you want to eat a three-course meal followed by cheese and
finish off a bottle of wine on the sofa, I want to say, “Enjoy! Can I join you?”
Equally, if you want to lose weight, then I would like to say “Good luck! Have
fun! Running in the rain is horrible!”
You can still be a feminist. You can hate beauty magazines
and the government telling you what size to be and what to eat – you can make
those choices yourself, to exercise or not to exercise, to diet or not to diet.
No matter what choice you make, in my opinion, you are no more or less a
feminist.
And now I’m going for a run. J
What an interesting post - as someone who suffered with anorexia throughout college, I've still somehow never really identified fat shaming as a feminist cause. I mean, I guess I have on some level, but not in such concrete terms. I think the problem is our society so often conflates "body weight" with "physical health." You can be at an above-average weight and still be healthy. It's a hard line to walk, because obesity can cause and exacerbate many chronic illnesses, and it is a huge burden on society (more so in the US, I guess - since we're the fattest nation in the world), but a girl who weighs 30lbs more than her peers shouldn't be thought of as just a problem to solve.
ReplyDeleteargh I just wrote a whole reply and then my internet died and lost it all... will try and repost later!
ReplyDeleteYou are so passionate!))) It's weight loss that makes you so hot?)))
ReplyDelete________
http://www.shoppharmacycounter.com/t-Adipex-Medicine.aspx